Warm bakery interior with freshly baked bread on wooden counters
Bath Beach, Brooklyn

Savor every
crumb of
tradition

For generations, our family has shaped dough by hand, slow-fermented every loaf, and baked with the same devotion that turns simple ingredients into something unforgettable.

Explore Our Menu Our Story
Scroll
Our Heritage

A legacy baked
with love

What began as a small family kitchen has grown into one of Brooklyn's most cherished bakeries — without ever compromising the methods that make every loaf, every tart, and every cake truly special.

Freshly baked artisan sourdough bread on a wooden board
01

Slow-Fermented Dough

Every batch rests for 24 to 48 hours — never rushed. This patience develops complex flavors and a crust that sings with every bite.

An assortment of golden pastries and croissants on a marble surface
02

Handcrafted Pastries

From buttery croissants to delicate tarts, each piece is shaped by hand — no machines, no shortcuts, just skill and attention to detail.

A baker pulling a tray of golden bread from a traditional brick oven
03

Community at Heart

Garcia Bakery isn't just a shop — it's a gathering place. Neighbors become friends over a fresh baguette and a cup of coffee.

Our Offerings

From our oven
to your table

Every item is made fresh daily in small batches — because quality is never something you compromise on.

Loaf of artisan sourdough bread with a flour-dusted crust
Signature

Artisan Sourdough

Our signature 48-hour fermented sourdough — crisp, caramelized crust with a tender, tangy crumb.

Learn More
Golden flaky croissants arranged on a white surface

French Pastries

Croissants, pain au chocolat, danishes — laminated with French butter and baked to golden perfection every morning.

Learn More
An elegant layered celebration cake with subtle frosting
Popular

Custom Cakes

Celebrations call for something extraordinary. Order a custom cake for birthdays, weddings, or any occasion that deserves to be remembered.

Learn More
A perfect espresso in a ceramic cup with latte art

Specialty Coffee

Single-origin beans, roasted to highlight their natural character. Espresso, pour-over, or a velvety cappuccino — each cup is pulled with care.

Learn More
Fresh focaccia bread topped with herbs and sea salt

Focaccia & Flatbreads

Herbed, olive-studded, tomato-topped — our focaccia is a work of art. Perfect as a side or the star of your meal.

Learn More
Seasonal fruit tarts with fresh berries and cream

Seasonal Specials

We follow the calendar — holiday stollen, spring lemon tarts, autumn pumpkin loaves. Something new to discover with every visit.

Learn More
Hands kneading dough dusted with flour
Premium baking ingredients: butter, eggs, flour arranged beautifully
A baker carefully shaping bread dough by hand
A bakery display case filled with beautiful pastries and breads
Est. Gen
The Craft

Patience is our
secret ingredient

In a world that rewards speed, we choose the opposite. Every loaf ferments slowly. Every pastry is layered by hand. Every cake is decorated with intention. This is not mass production — it is a craft, practiced daily with the same reverence our founders brought to this bakery decades ago.

1

Select the Finest Ingredients

Organic flour, European butter, free-range eggs, and locally sourced seasonal produce — we source only what we'd serve our own families.

2

Shape with Intention

No assembly lines here. Each piece is formed by hand, with the baker's experience guiding pressure, fold, and form.

3

Bake Until It Sings

We watch, we listen, we know by the sound of the crust. When it's ready, it comes out golden, fragrant, and ready for you.

The bread here tastes like something my grandmother used to make — before everything got industrialized. This is the real thing.

A Beloved Neighbor

Visit Us

Come share a
moment with us

Whether you're grabbing a morning coffee or picking up a celebration cake, we'd love to welcome you.

Location

1730 Bath Ave
New York, NY 11214-4531

Bath Beach, Brooklyn

Call Us

(134) 737-4933

For orders and inquiries

Hours

Mon – Fri: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM

Saturday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Sunday: 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Get in Touch

Have a question or want to place a custom order? Send us a message.

Brooklyn streetscape near Bath Avenue

Find us on Bath Ave

Nestled in the heart of Bath Beach, Garcia Bakery has been a cornerstone of the neighborhood — a place where the aroma of fresh bread welcomes you home.

Get Directions Call Us
Is this your business?This is my business